Hoaxlines

Share this post
Russia appears to be behind claims that Ukrainians are torturing each other
novelscience.substack.com
Reports

Russia appears to be behind claims that Ukrainians are torturing each other

A thread claiming to show Ukrainians mercilessly beating men, women, and children has gone viral. It appears tied to Russian state media and was shared over 20,000 times before it was removed.

Hoaxlines
Mar 22
1
Share this post
Russia appears to be behind claims that Ukrainians are torturing each other
novelscience.substack.com

NOTE: This is a working paper and has only been published early to prevent false narratives from spreading.

Updated: Shortly after 9 pm ET, Twitter suspended one of the accounts spreading the graphic disinformation videos, but the narrative was allowed to spread long after Twitter became aware of the account. The platform had deleted other earlier posts.

Update-2: Twitter suspended another account in this report. The original poster of the videos is telling people in the Telegram channel to post the videos from Telegram to Twitter.

Updated-3: Multiple suspended accounts have been reinstated on Twitter and are engaging in coordinated amplification of false narratives about Ukraine.


Videos claim to show Ukrainians torturing each other

A thread claiming to show Ukrainians mercilessly beating men, women, and children has gone viral. That Ukrainians could even be outside their homes with the non-stop shelling beggars belief. Still, I found a lot of questionable details about this account and the post, followers, and retweeters.

Account history

Archive history shows the user claimed to be from Scotland earlier but has since removed that from the profile. The account used to have a listed name that looked something like “Elon Musk,” at which point it promoted links for “eloninvest.org.” The account went dormant for a years-long period, as is common with inauthentic accounts.

The user is clearing 400 tweets per day, with the majority of tweets in support of pro-Kremlin narratives. This is an exceptionally high number of tweets, especially from an account that had no tweets for years before this.

TruthNest assesses the account as highly active and highly influential. Content from this user may be designed to reduce support for Ukrainians by portraying them as Nazis or violent. EUvsDisinfo covered “denazification” as one of the key long-term narratives for the Kremlin. The crisis actor claims didn’t work out, so maybe this is trying something new.

All of the user’s most popular tweets promote the idea that "the media" are conspiring to lie about what is happening in Ukraine. Almost all of the user’s tweets are pro-Kremlin. Genuine users — even when they are zealous activists — rarely focus on a singular topic like this. A "sole tweeting purpose" is a recognized indicator of inauthentic activity.

The percentage of activity from this account from replies is unusually high. Sometimes this can mean the account is a "reply guy.” Whether “the media” report on this or not, we can see what is happening in Ukraine from satellite.

A pinned tweet is a new pro-Kremlin OSINT account

The author of the pinned tweet is new and appears to be an OSINT account, possibly to gain traction using the popularity of OSINT accounts in gaining independent intelligence on the war.

The user has a backup account listed in the user’s bio. Already the account was suspended for Ukraine disinformation. It used a backup account to evade the ban and did so openly. Ban evasion is a policy violation so this account remaining online is disappointing.

Following and Followers

The account follows multiple Russian state media outlets and also employees, but used to appear to be from Scotland. Today it follows Spanish-language Russian state propaganda channels and hosts and is exceptionally focused on the situation in Ukraine—especially how much people don’t approve of Russian aggression. Additionally, the account follows a host from Iranian state TV and an account for the so-called People’s Republic of Lugansk.

Retweeters

Perhaps the most relevant connection is that an early retweeter of the torture videos also retweeted the account that seeded the maternity hospital disinformation narrative in the days before the attack (possibly suggesting foreknowledge) and spread false claims about one of the victims after the bombing. Russia has now repeated the pattern of claiming a location is a military base, bombing it, and then sowing incoherent narratives about what happened.

Some of the earliest accounts interact with the thread by tagging news outlets or highly influential figures in far-right politics or anti-vaccine movements. Another user who quote tweeted one of the disinformation tweets is posting about Lia Thomas, a transgender athlete, and vaccine requirements.

Older posts showing the torture content had been removed, but Twitter has allowed some of the accounts posting this content to increase and spread doubt about the claims of people being killed in Ukraine. It’s clear Twitter is aware of the account because it has removed other posts with similar videos.

One account that retweeted the original thread had a Telegram channel, so I looked at it.

Account has a preference for Russian state-affiliated author

The retweeter’s Telegram channel shares content from Andrew Korybko, who writes for at least a dozen Russian-state affiliated outlets, including Sputnik News to OneWorld.Press.1

The Telegram post link is an outlet recognized as controlled by the GRU. One World had the InfoRos logo in its directory. The GRU controls InfoRos. The US Treasury said of InfoRos:

The GRU operates InfoRos. InfoRos calls itself a news agency but is primarily run by the GRU’s 72nd Main Intelligence Information Center (GRITs). GRITs is a unit within Russia’s Information Operations Troops, which is identified as Russia’s military force for conducting cyber espionage, influence, and offensive cyber operations. InfoRos operates under two organizations, “InfoRos, OOO” and “IA InfoRos.”

Denazification narrative

Korybko circulated false claims about denazification recently. He’s still on Facebook spreading pro-Kremlin disinformation but should have been removed a long time ago for promoting 2020 election disinformation. At least two of these outlets are linked to Russian intelligence.

The channel is spreading disinformation about the Syrian use of chemical weapons and sharing content from authors affiliated that work for Russian-state media and an outlet affiliated with the GRU. The channel link history shows content from Global Research and Grayzone. Tribune.com.pk frequently published Russian state-affiliated authors.

Time is of the essence, so I'm sharing this now.


Twitter thread based on this report

Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
DISINFORMATION UPDATE THREAD: Russia appears linked to false claims that Ukrainians are torturing each other. The post was shared over 20,000 times before it was removed.
novelscience.substack.com/p/russia-appea…

E Rosalie @NovelSci

There is a disinformation campaign claiming to show the Ukrainians torturing people. I will post a report when I finish but this is important enough I want to say something now. The accounts are suspicious.

March 22nd 2022

273 Retweets434 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
1/ Archive history shows the user claimed to be from Scotland earlier—seems to have been into divisive posts—but has since removed that from the profile. The account also had an Elon Musk profile name for a while and posted spam.
Image

March 22nd 2022

14 Retweets61 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
2/ The user is clearing 400 tweets per day in support of pro-Kremlin narratives. This is an exceptionally high number of tweets, especially from an account that had no tweets for years before this.
Image

March 22nd 2022

15 Retweets83 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
3/ The user's most popular tweets promote the idea that "the media" are conspiring to lie about Ukraine. Genuine users, even when they are zealous activists, rarely focus on a "sole tweeting purpose. Research shows it's an indicator of inauthenticity.
mdpi.com/2076-3417/11/9…
Image

March 22nd 2022

17 Retweets68 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
4/ The author of the pinned tweet is new and appears to be an OSINT account, possibly to gain traction using the popularity of OSINT accounts in gaining independent intelligence on the war.
Image

March 22nd 2022

10 Retweets60 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
5/ The account has a backup account listed in the user’s bio. Already the account was suspended for Ukraine disinformation. It used a backup account to evade the ban and did so openly. Ban evasion is a policy violation so this account remaining online is disappointing.
Image
Image

March 22nd 2022

14 Retweets66 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
6/ The account follows multiple Russian state media outlets and also employees, but used to appear to be from Scotland. Today, it was following Spanish-language Russian state propaganda channels and hosts and is exceptionally focused on the situation in Ukraine.
Image

March 22nd 2022

14 Retweets59 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
7/ Examples for tweet 6
Image
Image
Image

March 22nd 2022

5 Retweets41 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
8/ Additionally, the account follows a host from Iranian state TV and an account for the so-called People’s Republic of Lugansk.
Image

March 22nd 2022

4 Retweets41 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
9/ An early retweeter of the torture videos also retweeted the account that seeded the maternity hospital disinformation narrative in the days before the attack (possibly suggesting foreknowledge) and spread false claims about one of the victims after the bombing.
Image
Image

March 22nd 2022

9 Retweets49 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
10/ Russia has now repeated the pattern (maternity hospital and drama theater) of claiming a location it attacked is a military base and sowing incoherent narratives about what happened.
Image

March 22nd 2022

12 Retweets57 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
11/ Some of the earliest users to engage, tagged news outlets or influencers in far-right politics or anti-vaccine movements. Another user who quote tweeted one of the disinformation tweets is posting about Lia Thomas, a transgender athlete, and vaccine requirements.
Image
Image

March 22nd 2022

13 Retweets46 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
12/ One account that retweeted the original thread had a Telegram channel, so I looked at it. The retweeter’s Telegram channel shares content from Andrew Korybko, who writes for at least a dozen Russian-state affiliated outlets, including Sputnik News to OneWorld[.]Press
Image

March 22nd 2022

11 Retweets46 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
13/ The Telegram post link is an outlet recognized as controlled by the GRU. One World had the InfoRos logo in its directory. The GRU controls InfoRos, per US treasury.
home.treasury.gov/news/press-rel…
Image

March 22nd 2022

10 Retweets43 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
14/ Korybko circulated false claims about denazification recently. He’s still on Facebook spreading pro-Kremlin disinformation but should have been removed long ago for promoting 2020 election disinformation. At least two of these outlets are linked to Russian intelligence.
Image
Image

March 22nd 2022

8 Retweets45 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
15/ This author has the distinction of being an author for the state-media trifecta Russia
archive.ph/02RKN China archive.ph/RAd7v Iran (interviewed for article) archive.ph/0zRFT
Image
Image
Image
Image

March 22nd 2022

10 Retweets38 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
16/ The channel is spreading disinformation about the Syrian use of chemical weapons and the channel link history shows content from Global Research, Grayzone, and Tribune[.]com[.]pk frequently published Russian state-affiliated authors.
Image
Image

March 22nd 2022

7 Retweets33 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
17/ There will be more but it was important to get some of the evidence out, given that there are people in the West on the far right and left that are fooled by this disinformation.
Russia appears linked to false claims Ukrainians are torturing each otherA thread claiming to show Ukrainians mercilessly beating men, women, and children has gone viral. It appears tied to Russian state media and was shared over 20,000 times before it was removed.novelscience.substack.com

March 22nd 2022

18 Retweets43 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
18/ Слава Украине. Слава Україні.
Image

March 22nd 2022

6 Retweets51 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
19/ Update--Twitter suspended another disinfo account in my report. The original poster of the videos is telling people in the Telegram channel to post the videos from Telegram to Twitter. @TwitterSafety, please pay attention to this. I warned about it almost a month ago.
Image
Image

March 22nd 2022

9 Retweets40 Likes
Twitter avatar for @NovelSciE Rosalie @NovelSci
20/ Both the account that originally posted the violent videos and a second account suspended by Twitter were previously amplified by a conservative influencer. The Ukrainian maps account was pinned to the violent video poster's profile and was shared by Posobiec.
Image

March 22nd 2022

6 Retweets22 Likes

Share

1

Korybko articles:

  • CGTN (2022) - Chinese state media

  • Frontier India (2022)

  • ForeignPolicyNews.org (2021)

  • Francophone Saker (2022)

  • Freepen.gr (2022)

  • Geopolitica.ru (2019)

  • Global Research (2022)

  • Global Village Space (2021)

  • Global Times (2022)

  • Planetes360.fr (2022)

  • PressTV (2021)- article cites Korybko as a source - Iranian state media

  • ModernDiplomacy.eu (2022)

  • Off-Guardian (2021)

  • OneWorld.Press (2022)

  • RussianCouncil.ru (2021)

  • Sputnik News (2022)

  • Tribune.com.pk (2021)

  • TheAltWorld (2021)

  • Theprint.in

  • TheWire.in (2021)

  • USA Really (2018)

  • Voice of the East (2021)

  • Whispers from the North (2022)

Share this post
Russia appears to be behind claims that Ukrainians are torturing each other
novelscience.substack.com
Comments

Create your profile

0 subscriptions will be displayed on your profile (edit)

Skip for now

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.

TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2022 Novel Science
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing